6:18 pm // Learning (thanks to Dr Zakir Naik)
I was once told by someone that if you pause for a minute and listen to others you will learn a lot. I asked him, but if they are uttering non-sense?
To which he replied, “then you will learn even better, you will learn what not to say”.
I was also told that you can never know everything, so learn how to simply admit you have no clue about it. After all no Human can be with an infinite knowledge, and there is no shame or insult in admitting that simple fact.
My sister sent me a video clip today of Dr Zakir Naik, a Muslim religious scholar quite famous worldwide among Muslims for his comparative religious studies (he can recall from memory complete religious books of all the major faiths), and hated initially by many non-Muslims (specifically hardline Hindus in India, where he is from) who considered him as a threat to their religious views and now recently by fellow Muslims since he said some things which hurt the sectarian sensitivities and also by some religious Scholars since he has no formal isnad (certification or affiliation) and he pose a threat to their “stature”.
This particular clip (can be watched on youtube, here) is pretty interesting because first of all he makes virtually no sense to me at least on any factual basis (or from any proper religious reference) and sadly not even on any logical ground (by standards of my logic). Then second, you can see that the young guy is simply unconvinced and he tries to get back in at 2:30 whereas at around 3:00 Dr Zakir seems to be losing his ground to him, and explicitly at 3:33 you can see some people discouraging him and he is for a while drowned in clapping from the people who obviously seem to be agreeing with him. And at 3:50 you get the “best bit”, agree or burn in the eternal fire of hell!
This is not the first time Dr Zakir Naik has done so, his previous discussion on why Pork is Haram (forbidden) where he literally meant to validate the Cannibals’ point of view that when you eat something you get their traits in yourself (and made me doubt his medical degree even. By the way, I follow this way more sensible reason also echoed by this Christian evangelist available on Youtube). Or another place when on a Pakistani TV channel he in such a weird way defended the Saudi Arabian Government’s stance of not letting people of other faith build their place of worships (talk about discrimination against Muslims in non-Muslim lands, or maybe Minarate ban in Switzerland - right?), that I for a while felt ashamed!
I really have one thing to say to Dr Zakir, and that is perhaps he should consider drawing some line for his expertise. He being a doctor must already know that a cardiologist doesn’t touch the brain, no matter how much an experienced cardiologist he is. Therefore he might wish to go back to being an expert in Comparative religion rather than being a Mufti or an Ayotullah. Or at least he should decide that next time if he doesn’t know an answer, he should excuse and say ‘my knowledge is limited’.
Anyway a little exchange I had with my sister on this which prompted me to write this:
Sis: So I committed Shirk because I wished my Christian friends marry Christmas?
Me: shabash! Stop listening to this man!
Sis: I dont get it seriously and I think its the most stupid thing I have ever heard..the kid wasnt convinced though
Me: ZN reminds me that never I will have complete knowledge. And therefore, I should not try to act like a person who has command over everything! And don’t worry even if we are Kafir now, at least we are still brother and sister :)